Showing posts with label Birgit Matthiesen. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Birgit Matthiesen. Show all posts

Friday, December 14, 2012

BTB: Bilateralist Reports on Progress, and (Relative) Risk to North American Exporters

Luiza Ch. Savage, at her blog Bilateralist and at Mclean's D.C. correspondent, shared an excellent BTB update chart prepared by Birgit Matthiesen that details and has and has not been accomplished by the governments of Canada and the United States.

You can find Matthiesen's 2-page side-by-side comparison here, and Savage's Maclean's article here.

Savage, not getting buried in details, succinctly gets to the 'impact' of differing rates of success on BTB's various objectives:
This is complicated stuff and no one expects overnight changes. But timing matters, too. For example, the governments reported progress on a pilot projects for harmonizing cargo screening for North-America-bound cargo at the ports of Prince Rupert and Montreal. There is a risk that quick progress on such“perimeter” elements coupled with slow progress on expediting the land border between Canada and the U.S. could inadvertently disadvantage North American manufacturers relative to exporters from, say, Asia or Europe.
Says Birgit Matthiesen, the Washington representative for the Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters:

“With the increased competition from third countries in the last few years, and what is anticipated from the TPP and Canada-EU trade agreement, manufacturers in Canada and the U.S., and their business partners, are going to be looking for real relief from transactional costs and compliance burdens at the land border. If not, the North American supply chain could be at a competitive disadvantage.”

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

President Obama’s Re-Election—for Obvious and Less Obvious Reasons—May Push the Canada-U.S. Relationship to Center-Stage

By Keith Edmund White 

Will Obama’s second term put the Canada-U.S. relationship on center-stage?  A quick round-up of Canadian headlines shows three major issues dominating the post-election Canada-U.S. relationship: (1) in the short-term, Canadian apprehension over America’s ability to reach a debt deal, (2) Keystone XL, and (3) moving forward on the Beyond the Border Initiative.  But let’s not forget two other wrinkles from America’s election night: Heidi Heitkamp’s Senate win and the failure of a state constitutional roadblock to the Detroit River Crossing Project.  And when you add to this Canada’s critical role in the Trans-Pacific Partnership talks, the Canada-U.S. relationship will be getting its fair due during Obama’s second term.

BC’s The Tyee offers a cautious Canadian reaction to President Obama’s re-election.  The article's two chief points: (1) If Obama does not reach a debt deal with Congressional Republicans, who still hold the U.S. House of Representatives, America could tumble into recession, and drag Canada along for the ride; and (2) hope that Obama will clear full construction of the Keystone XL pipeline.  But The Hill calls Keystone XL an energy election-night ‘loser,’ seeing a Romney White House fast-tracking the project.  My guess: with Keystone XL already under construction, I don’t expect the Obama administration to stall Keystone XL’s northern construction much longer.

But, in any case, Heidi Heitkamp’s Senate victory in North Dakota guarantees one strong, Democratic voice in favor of the pipe-line.

And then, of course, one major pit-fall in Canada-U.S. relations was avoided.  Yesterday Michigan voters shot down a state constitutional amendment that would have delayed—and perhaps killed—plans to build a second, bridge crossing connecting Detroit to Windsor over the Detroit River—a project with obvious economic impact in both Canada and the United States, and strongly supported by Canadian Prime Minster Harper.

But one less reported story bears mentioning.  December 2011’s Beyond the Border Initiative (BTB), a Canada-U.S. project to streamline border regulations and bolster border security, might get a jump start.   Birgit Matthiesen offers this BTB post-election update for the Canadian Manufacturers & Exporters:
Over the last four years, Canada has too often benignly neglected by our neighbour. But the next four years presents an opportunity to build a North American manufacturing base. The US business community has a partner in Canada. One-third of our cross border business is intra-company and another third is comprised of intra-industry shipments. Our best ideas are each other's next new product.

The ball is in our court, as it always is when dealing with an American administration. But we do not have to start at square one.

Two initiatives between President Obama and Prime Minister Harper have already been launched – the Beyond the Border Action Plan and the Regulatory Cooperation Council. The ambition is great, but the progress is slow. Now that the elections are behind us, Ottawa and Washington need to get back to the table on these two efforts.

We have a major opportunity right now. 2013 must be the year that celebrates our cross-border partnership and the strength that our industries bring to each other's communities. Obsolete border management policies and unnecessary regulations must be replaced by a modern framework that will protect us from the economic storms ahead.
But, the big story—and not once mentioned on cable news last night—is that an Obama victory will continue progress, without the interruption of a presidential transition, on the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP).  As earlier reported on CUSLI-Nexus, Canada may likely play a critical role in ensuring these talks succeed.  And if this massive trade deal succeeds, it will likely—over the medium and long-term—generate more economic growth--and, at times, painful economic shifting--than any stimulus or jobs bill.  Furthermore, how the TPP goes may well portend how the future effectiveness of the World Trade Organization. 

What’s the importance of listing these seemingly unattached policy items?  First, it seems that two big pressure points in the Canada-U.S. relationship—Keystone XL and the International Detroit River Crossing—have (or soon will be) taken care of.  Next, Canada represents low-hanging economic fruit for the United States.  And—after Obama does heavy lifting on a debt deal and a job bill—the name of the White House economic strategy will be (with one major exception) connecting small dots to generate growth.  One major and needless U.S. economic drain?  Canada-U.S. border regulatory burdens that could be eased through smart, cooperative policies.

Now, naysayers may argue the United States has had trouble keeping focus on Canada.   But, if the TPP talks keep moving ahead, the United States simply won’t have this luxury.  Hence, whether pushed by state-specific issues or international trade diplomacy, the Canada-U.S. relationship may just see its fair share of time on center-stage during Obama's second term
.

Friday, March 23, 2012

CUSLI 2012 Conference: Afternoon Panel #1 -- 'Trade and Jobs'

by Keith Edmund White


Chaired by Juscelino Colares, Prof. CWRU Law. This panel will discuss the proposed Trade and Jobs section of the Action Plan and determine how it addresses problems the U.S. and Canada face with trade and jobs. The discussion will then turn to other legal agreements that will influence trade and jobs in the future.
  • Paul Vandevert, In House Counsel, Ford Motor Co.
  • Birgit Matthiesen, Canadian Manufacturers & Exporters
  • Dick Cunningham, Int’l Trade Atty at Steptoe and Johnson LLP


Below are (rough) summaries of the panelists' remarks.

Paul Vandevert:  "...I have some practical concerns" about the Beyond the Border Initiative, Namely Why Can't Our Regulations Deal With Global Supply Chains?

“To be blunt,” Vandevert stated, “I have some practical concerns [about the BTB Initiative].”  If there’s trade facilitation, the private sector will take care the jobs part.  Thus, Vandevert focused on the trade side of the Canada-US border relationship, and about the need of actually putting trade and security together—something that it appears has not happened yet. 

The job of government is to secure and keep the channels of trade often, the private sector will take care of the trade.  But, Vandevert stated, mostly from the American side we talk facilitation and trade, but “We continue to put security first…”  And when we’re done with that, “we’ll get to trade facilization.”

He noted that the plan states that a “fundamental” responsibility is to identity every shipment of ocean cargo.  For goods coming into the United States from across the oceans,Information of each shipment must be filed within 24 hours of the cargo being loaded.  From his personnel experiences in dealing with this, that every shipper and importer to fill out who shipped, who the consignee is, and description of goods.  And in a number of industries, including the auto industry, we do a number of high-volume, highly repetitive trade interactions.  So, we have continuous and routinizied goods coming in.  But when we went to customs to put that into their system ahead of time, we—Vandevert stated—were refused.

The implication I draw  from the action plan that the intention from at least the US costums side, they will apply—for security purposes..—they will apply the same transactional approach over the border.  “I don’t see how it will work.”  “They are doing a complete do-over,” he stated, “and every day is  going to be a new day…even though the same traders are doing the same thing, every day…it’s the extreme version of Groundhog’s Day.”  Is such a transactional approach really going to foster trade, and does it secure the border?  Also, as Vandevert pointed out, how will costumes build up the knowledge base to know what trade flows are normal and not.

What’s the other way?  Vandevert shared that we could give information earlier, and there is already information out there that is collected through NAFTA and other programs, “in which there have been enforcement mechanisms…that the customs authority have learned about about the trading community and should be relying on that.”
               
Birgit Matthiesen:  “I go around Washington telling people we’re not China…you know us." And  Why Aren't We Requiring All Border-Related Regulatory Changes to Be Evaluated on How They Impact Canada-U.S. Manufacturing, and Haven't We Heard All This Positive Crossborder Talk for the last 25 years?

Matthiesen noted that, beside the positive words shared earlier, that there is skepticism about whether BTB initiative will work.  We need to look at why we’re doing all these efforts, and what has changed to make this agreement so important? 

Twenty-five years ago these same plans we’re talked about, and the regulatory issues talked about today were talked about today.  And since 9/11, we’ve seen a surge of manufactured goods from Asia.  But this means that North American manufacturing has a huge challenge in our own backyard.

And this challenge, Matthiesen continued, will only grow with both nations are continuing FTAs.  And, to top things off, we’re adding fees to the Canada-US trade relationship to pay for the increased goods coming into the nations from other countries. 

We’re way past cost-shaving.  But a lot of companies are sitting on a lot of money because they don’t know where to invest to grow their production.   And we need to get these two agreements, the border and regulation, are so important.  We’re all about North American manufacturing.

Matthisen concluded with two challenges:  (1) to the government officials, I know the border has two pieces—the perimeter and the land border.  I will be looking for, at the end of the day, if the land border portion makes and supports North American manufacturing, and closer sharing along the perimeter to a competitive edge to the imported goods from aboard?  We have to do both together.  And (2), to the law students, she wants to know that if there’s one rule that practically reflects the integration of North America and supports the manufacturing of North America.  Before we do final rules, can we review regulatory rules to add another criteria:  does this support or not support North American manufacturing?  Answering these questions, Matthiesen concluded, is critical to understand the reasoning for what we’re hoping to accomplish with our security and regulatory relationship and if legal changes we’re planning to do actually do this.

Richard O. Cunningham:  How Do We Deal with the Job Problem—And Can We?

Cunningham went over the choices U.S. policy makers have to create jobs, and revealed that all the choices present downsides that can actually lead to their own job loss.  In doing so, he showed how there are not simple levers to pull when it comes to created jobs in a liberalized trading system.  And he sees this tension as perhaps coming to a head soon should the Trans-Pacific Partnership discussions yield a agreement.  If such an event occurs, the U.S. political class and general public will have to deal with the fact that the interests of multi-national, U.S. firms and the interests of the general public in quick job-growth do not align.  The outcome?  Only time will tell.

Simulate demand.  But, as Cunningham points out, such policies will lead to imports and national goods being consumed.  So, it’s a double-edged sword.

Education.  The education to simulate jobs is not academic, but rather more on the German model, Cunningham cautioned.  We need high-skilled, but not brain-powered jobs.  That is a long-term solution.

Trade—Increase Exports.  Now here its clear the administration is on the ball with goals, but how do we increase exports?  Well, the “dirty secret” Cunningham stated, is making our currency cheaper.  But, in the long-term, this may have people say this is “getting us in binds we don’t want to get into.”  And then there’s export bank initiatives, but with when Air India buys the American jets Delta announces they can’t compete and has to cut flights.  And, on top of this, it requires government funding, which Cunningham stated, is very difficult in this climate.

“The most dramatic change in trade I’ve seen in forty years of doing this," is that trade priorities are changing for U.S. businesses because businesses are changing what they want.  They don’t want to export goods from the U.S., but rather they want global supply changes to get lower labor costs and favorable regulatory changes.  One key example, Cunningham stated, was the exchange between Obama and Jobs:  Jobs made clear that Apple jobs in China aren’t coming back to America.  Why?  Mobilizing financing, workers and regulatory conditions to facilitate Apple productions.

Growth Markets in the Emerging Countries of South Asia, China, and India, but these are the countries where the trade barriers remain.  How do we fix this?  Get the developing countries to reduce their barriers, and they don’t want to play this game without major concessions on agriculture and other matters the developed countries don’t want to budge on.  And how are we trying to deal with this?  The Trans-Pacific  Partnership is focusing on the behind the border issues.  Private industry holds more hope in the TPP than Doha is resolving trade policy differences between developed countries and the emerging economies.  And, if the TPP comes up with a agreement, the body politic will have to face the difference between (1) promoting jobs and (2) promoting growth for multinational firms.