CUSLI Nexus is will taking a holiday break until the new year.
Thanks for your readership, and--fear not--new posts in the New Year await.
Saturday, December 22, 2012
Thursday, December 20, 2012
Supreme Court of Canada Offers Test to Permit Removal of Testifying Witness's Niqab (Read the Dissent)
You can read the full (and rather short) decision here, courtesy of CanLII. In short, a niqab can be removed; decision offers a very mushy, skeleton test; remands back to preliminary court to do the test.
I think the most compelling writing must go to the dissent by Rosalie Silberman Abella, which blows serious holes in the "demeanor ideal" be pushed by the majority, and shows a potential and very serious ill-effect of the majority's rule: a sexual assault victim may "be forced to choose between laying a complaint and wearing a niqab, which may be no meaningful choice at all."
The dissent also uses the most effective (or, depending on your position, manipulative) rhetorical tools to convey its message, not an unusual advantage when writing the losing side.
Highlights--majority holding:
- Four-inquiry, factor test that goes against having a "clear rule" in favor or removing or not removing a witness's niqab:
- (1) does removal "interfere with her religious freedom"?
- (2) permitting niqab "create a serious risk to trail fairness" (i.e. uncontested testimony doesn't require removal)?
- (3) alternative means (totally punts this to the trial judge to figure out)
- (4) "do the salutary effects of requiring the witness to remove the niqab outweigh the deleterious effects of doing so?" [The key inquiry]
- Test for inquiry (4):
- "The judge must assess all these factors ["importance of religious practice to the witness," "state interference" with that practice, "actual situation" in court, "societal harms," and interest of the accused and nature of the evidence (yeah that last one blurs with (3)).] and determine whether the salutary effects of requiring the witness to remove the niqab outweigh the deleterious effects of doing so."
Highlights--concurrence (agrees with test, but makes clear preference for a "clear rule" that niqab may be removed):
- From this broader constitutional perspective, the trial becomes an act of communication with the public at large. The public must be able to see how the justice system works. Wearing a niqab in the courtroom does not facilitate acts of communication. Rather, it shields the witness from interacting fully with the parties, their counsel, the judge and the jurors. Wearing the niqab is also incompatible with the rights of the accused, the nature of the Canadian public adversarial trials, and with the constitutional values of openness and religious neutrality in contemporary democratic, but diverse, Canada. Nor should wearing a niqab be dependent on the nature or importance of the evidence, as this would only add a new layer of complexity to the trial process. A clear rule that niqabs may not be worn at any stage of the criminal trial would be consistent with the principle of public openness of the trial process and would safeguard the integrity of that process as one of communication.
- Rule: "Unless the witness’s face is directly relevant to the case, such as where her identity is in issue, she should not be required to remove her niqab."
- All of these are departures [permitting stroke victims, use of interpreter] to testify, from the demeanour ideal, yet none has ever been held to disqualify the witness from giving his or her evidence on the grounds that the accused’s fair trial rights are impaired. Witnesses who wear niqabs should not be treated any differently.
- "A witness who is not permitted to wear her niqab while testifying is prevented from being able to act in accordance with her religious beliefs. This has the effect of forcing her to choose between her religious beliefs and her ability to participate in the justice system. As a result, complainants who sincerely believe that their religion requires them to wear the niqab in public, may choose not to bring charges for crimes they allege have been committed against them, or, more generally, may resist being a witness in someone else’s trial. Where the witness is the accused, she will be unable to give evidence in her own defence. "
- "The majority’s conclusion that being unable to see the witness’s face is acceptable from a fair trial perspective if the evidence is 'uncontested', essentially means that sexual assault complainants, whose evidence will inevitably be contested, will be forced to choose between laying a complaint and wearing a niqab, which may be no meaningful choice at all.
Toronto Mayoral Election Shake-Up: Ranked Ballots In 2018?
Maclean's reports on Dave Meslin's impressive efforts to get ranked elections up and running in Toronto by 2018:
In this latest poll’s scenarios, for instance, Chow would beat Ford and a range of competitors. Without her in the race though, Ford would beat a range of three- or four-way splits against him. The poll’s results are exasperating in their attempts to puzzle through all the permutations: Chow, Ford, Vaughan, and Carroll; Chow, Ford, Tory, Vaughan and Carroll; Chow, Chow, Chow, eggs and Chow; Ford, Vaughan, eggs, sausage and Chow, and so on.
These are not the makings of a fruitful conversation. Canadians like to grouse about our first-past-the-post elections, but have been reluctant to abandon their simplicity. Four provincial referenda on full-scale reworkings of provincial governments have failed. In Toronto, though, a more manageable change might be in the works.
In Toronto, Dave Meslin, a kinetic, well-known public advocate, has spent the past year lining up support for ranked ballots, a system that could bring election results more in line with what the majority of voters would prefer. Meslin has assembled a roster of city councillors who’ve endorsed his drive, including some of Rob Ford’s staunch conservative allies, who’ve taken both Meslin and and his proposal to their town halls, where the idea seems to have been warmly received. The logistics of preparing for an election has ruled out 2014, but in order to prod the provincial government into rewriting election laws to open the door for 2018, Meslin and his allies hope to see a council vote that will get the ball rolling this coming spring.
It works like this: Instead of voting for one candidate, voters would instead rank the candidates in order of preference. When the votes are counted, if a single candidate has 50% of the first-choice vote, they win. If nobody reaches 50%, then the last-place finisher is dropped from the ballot, and their supporters’ second-choice votes are distributed. The votes are counted again, and the process repeats itself until someone has secured 50% of the vote.
Maclean's Talks Canadian Wild Turkey Hunting
Not only an enjoyable read, but shows the many interesting ways states and provinces can find new revenue--and the terrible trouble wild turkeys can make.
From yesterday's Talking turkey article:
From yesterday's Talking turkey article:
...
If given the go-ahead, Wilson and others will travel to Ontario this winter, where they plan to use air-powered net cannons to trap 200 of the province’s estimated 70,000 wild turkeys. The birds will be tested for diseases, put in crates and shipped east to be released. They plan to repeat the process every winter for four years, aiming to more than double the existing population from 600 to 1,400, not including any natural increase. A biologist with the turkey federation estimates New Brunswick could support 10,000 birds.
One reason the province is considering a hunt is the money. Maine started its own program with 40 stocked birds in 1977 and now has roughly 60,000, says Northrup. Each year the hunt generates millions of dollars in spinoff revenue for the state. For every New Brunswick hunter who heads south to bag a bird, that’s money the province loses.
Yet many farmers are horrified at the idea of importing more of the birds, because wild turkeys are known for their voracious appetites. In Ontario, for instance, the birds are regularly blamed for devastating crops. With more than 300 wild blueberry farms in New Brunswick, there’s a lot at stake.
Wednesday, December 19, 2012
Dawson Strategic's December Briefing: A TPP Holiday Season
For readers interested in the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), do check out Dawson Strategic's December briefing. Whether on the big-picture, or the leading issues within the TPP talks, the briefing's three articles are must-reads.
One particularly interesting section of Dawson Strategic's December article, The TPP: What's In It For Canada?:
One particularly interesting section of Dawson Strategic's December article, The TPP: What's In It For Canada?:
Beyond its defensive interests, the TPP is a central component of Canada’s Asian and emerging markets strategy. Much of 2013 will likely be spent reconciling the trade rule-making interests and capacities of advanced industrialized economies with those of emerging economies such as Vietnam and Peru. Advanced economies like the U.S., New Zealand, Australia and Canada will bump up against each other on issues like investor-state dispute settlement and dairy market access, but there will be relatively few fireworks. In areas like intellectual property and labour mobility, the commitments that Canada is making with the EU are likely to go much deeper than anything we can expect from the TPP.
Image of the Day: Canada-U.S. Trade
The Globe and Mail offers some interesting graphs of where Canadian business leaders think their export market heading in the near-future.
Check out all the results and related articles here, but this graph was the most surprising--showing that most participants believing America's share of Canada's export market will stay the same or even increase:
Check out all the results and related articles here, but this graph was the most surprising--showing that most participants believing America's share of Canada's export market will stay the same or even increase:
Let's Get Over "Net Benefit" Test Carping: Or Why Political Law is Still Law...and the World's Still Here
By Keith Edmund White, Editor-in-Chief
More complaining about the dreaded political nature of Canada's revamped "net benefit" test. Critics seem to be saying, 'If a law's a law, it should always be transparent and consistent--just like jury decisions!' Keith Edmund White looks at Don Lenihan's criticism of the Harper government new rules of foreign takeovers (i.e. the "net benefit" test), and stands up for the messy, status quo the revamped rules leave in place. Added bonus: mention of Conrad Black.
Don Lenihan, Vice President at Ottawa’s Public Policy Forum, hits the Harper government’s new rules on foreign takeovers of strategic Canadian industries (and compliments Conrad Black).
From Lenihan’s iPolitics article:
But what will keep Canada from deterring smart foreign investment? Simple: If Canada drives away smart investment, it will feel it where it counts--the pocket-book.
Sure, this approach may not have the gossamer shine (and superficiality) of administrative consistency, but there are legal issues that societies do not settle through bright-line rules. And those issues tend to be that way for a reason.
And Lenihan's critique--making a new sub-set of rules for SOEs that comply with private sector practices--shows just how illusory the quest for a Black-ian "net benefit" middle-ground is. The more Canada tries to make rules for all possible foreign takeover scenarios, the longer the rule becomes, perhaps to the point of incomprehensibility--and the easier it is manipulated. Just ask anti-Affordable Care advocates how they feel about the ACA being considered a 'tax' and not a 'mandate' by the controlling opinion of the Supreme Court, thereby passing U.S. constitutional muster. The point: rules don't always bring clarity, especially when they are voluminous and involve hot-button issues.
Oh, and wait, we're worried, in the case of Chinese state-owned enterprise CNOOC takeover of Nexen, of Canada's notoriously illiberal society negatively impacting the struggling, still-malleable but liberal-idolizing economy of China?
Check out one notable exception to the chorus of "net benefit" naysayers, Jeffrey Simpson's article in last week's The Globe and Mail:
Is it a workable system for a sensitive topic in a democratic society? Sure seems that way.
In any case, Lenihan should check out the Journal of Parliamentary and Political Law.
Also, to all readers, know that the world (and Canada) will survive the new "net benefit" test; just like the world (and Canada) survived the last one.
From Lenihan’s iPolitics article:
If we really are at the beginning of a long-term trend that will force the federal government to begin employing controversial (possibly highly controversial) measures to protect Canada’s strategic assets, the goal of the policy should be to ensure that the decisions are transparent, effective and fair.Lenihan echoes the worries of many commentators about Canada’s vague “net benefit” rules. The tacit underlying assumption of Lenihan’s critique: all legal determinations should be consistent and transparent. But aren’t foreign takeovers of critical Canadian industries (or of any nation) as political—as say—the political and inconsistent decisions to raise or lower taxes or conclude a foreign investment treaties? And in the case of foreign takeovers, are any two Canadian industries really the same?
Unfortunately, on this score the new rules raise more questions than they answer. Do we really want to include all SOEs under one catch-all rule? If an SOE is willing to comply with the same rules as private sector companies, should this make a difference?
If the policy allows “exceptional circumstances” to override the rules, how will these be defined? How will the government deal with future private sector cases that are similar to the Saskatchewan Potash Corp? What other resources or industries could be declared strategic assets?
What options are open to the government to create the kind of “middle ground solution” proposed by Black?
But what will keep Canada from deterring smart foreign investment? Simple: If Canada drives away smart investment, it will feel it where it counts--the pocket-book.
Sure, this approach may not have the gossamer shine (and superficiality) of administrative consistency, but there are legal issues that societies do not settle through bright-line rules. And those issues tend to be that way for a reason.
And Lenihan's critique--making a new sub-set of rules for SOEs that comply with private sector practices--shows just how illusory the quest for a Black-ian "net benefit" middle-ground is. The more Canada tries to make rules for all possible foreign takeover scenarios, the longer the rule becomes, perhaps to the point of incomprehensibility--and the easier it is manipulated. Just ask anti-Affordable Care advocates how they feel about the ACA being considered a 'tax' and not a 'mandate' by the controlling opinion of the Supreme Court, thereby passing U.S. constitutional muster. The point: rules don't always bring clarity, especially when they are voluminous and involve hot-button issues.
Oh, and wait, we're worried, in the case of Chinese state-owned enterprise CNOOC takeover of Nexen, of Canada's notoriously illiberal society negatively impacting the struggling, still-malleable but liberal-idolizing economy of China?
Check out one notable exception to the chorus of "net benefit" naysayers, Jeffrey Simpson's article in last week's The Globe and Mail:
China [owner of Cnooc who put in the bid for Nexen] wants things both ways: that its SOEs can buy elsewhere but others can’t buy in China. That the Harper government has now identified a sector of the Canadian economy essentially off-limits to SOEs can’t logically be objected to by China, which puts big swaths of its economy out of reach of foreign investment or insists that foreign companies can only buy minority interests or participate in joint ventures.Is this the best system? Probably not.
China has been pursuing a policy of locking up natural resources wherever they can be profitably bought, and Canada seemed a likely next target. If China doesn’t like the new Canadian guidelines, there are plenty of other opportunities around the world. If China chooses not to test the guidelines, Alberta’s bitumen oil will still interest other investors.
The challenges of bitumen oil are so many that the new guidelines’ impact is among the least threatening. The changing oil scene in the United States, the difficulty of getting approval for pipelines, the growing emissions of greenhouse gases, the discount price for oil to the U.S. and high production costs are among the industry’s key challenges.
Mr. Harper, whose foreign policy is too often characterized by finger-waving intransigence, struck a reasonable balance in this instance between domestic interests and international concerns.
Is it a workable system for a sensitive topic in a democratic society? Sure seems that way.
In any case, Lenihan should check out the Journal of Parliamentary and Political Law.
Also, to all readers, know that the world (and Canada) will survive the new "net benefit" test; just like the world (and Canada) survived the last one.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

